The 1897 airship mystery and the Aurora, Texas crash

Lights over Sacramento, a prayer meeting in Nebraska, a Kansas cow carried into the sky, and a Martian buried in a Texas cemetery: the Great Airship Wave, fifty years before the flying saucer.

In February 1897, about ten people returning from a prayer meeting at Inavale, Nebraska, said they watched a flying machine pass overhead. It was perhaps thirty or forty feet long, with a bright headlight, six smaller lights along its sides, two sets of wings, and a large fan-shaped rudder. Some of them heard machinery. Some said they heard voices and laughter from the people on board. The Omaha Daily Bee printed the account on February 5.

Powered, controlled flight was still years away. The Wright brothers would not fly at Kitty Hawk until December 1903. And yet the witnesses did not describe a flying saucer, a visitor from another star, or a crew of small gray beings. The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell opens its chapter “Before the Flying Saucer” with this sighting, and with the plain fact of what the people of Inavale concluded: “They believed they had seen an airship.” Someone, somewhere, had built a marvelous machine. The occupants were assumed to be people. Over the winter and spring of 1896 and 1897, American newspapers printed hundreds of accounts like it. The episode became known as the Great Airship Wave, and, in Dell's words, “The skies had not necessarily changed. But the stories people told about them had.”

Sacramento, November 1896

The wave began in California. On the evening of November 17, 1896, people in Sacramento saw a bright light moving slowly across the sky, sometimes seeming to rise and fall. The evening was overcast. Most witnesses saw only the light. A few said they could make out a dark, elongated body behind it, and a few said they heard voices from overhead, talking, laughing, or singing. The light came back on later nights and was reported over Oakland, San Francisco, and other towns around the bay.

The San Francisco Call gave the story heavy coverage and published a dramatic drawing of a flying machine above the city. Dell is careful about that picture. It was not a photograph. “It was an artist's interpretation of disputed testimony.” The Sacramento Daily Record-Union was cooler. In an editorial headed “Air Fancies” on November 20, it agreed that many people had seen a strange light, but noted that only a few claimed to have seen an actual machine, and fewer still could describe one. The editors doubted that a revolutionary aircraft could be built and flown near the city without anyone reliable noticing, and suggested that the more elaborate stories had grown through talk and practical joking. The difference between an unexplained light and a story about a ship was being argued over in 1896.

The inventor who never appeared

During the excitement, a San Francisco attorney, George D. Collins, told reporters he represented the man behind it all: an inventor with a working airship, kept near Oroville, about sixty miles from Sacramento, and soon to be unveiled. Collins was mocked in the papers as “Airship” Collins and backed away from most of what he had said. A former state attorney general, William H. H. Hart, then claimed to speak for the inventor himself. No machine was ever shown. No inventor came forward. The story faded and the sightings went on.

Dell sees in this a pattern that would repeat for a century: “An unexplained observation attracts public attention. Someone claims inside knowledge. An extraordinary explanation is offered. A decisive demonstration is promised. But the evidence never arrives.” Secrecy and unusual lights were linked long before modern claims about hidden alien programs. “People did not need a government agency hiding alien spacecraft to imagine a secret project. A mysterious inventor working behind closed doors was sufficient.”

The wave moves east

California went quiet toward the end of 1896. Then, at the start of February 1897, the airship turned up on the Great Plains. The first Nebraska report came from Hastings: a light that seemed to hang nearly still, circle, travel a few miles, and stop again. The Norfolk News answered with a joke about what brand of liquor the Hastings correspondent was drinking. Inavale followed, with its prayer meeting. Over the next months the airship was reported at Beatrice, Kearney, Omaha, and dozens of smaller places. Writing in Nebraska History in 1979, the folklorist Roger L. Welsch counted nearly two hundred sightings in Nebraska newspapers alone, a mix of observations, arguments, jokes, and outright hoaxes.

By March the reports had spread into Kansas. At Belleville, people watched a light for several evenings, and the Kansas City Star suggested they were looking at the planet Venus, which can look astonishingly bright near the horizon. In Topeka, on the evening of March 27, Governor John W. Leedy was among those who saw a red light in the sky, and Harold T. Chase, editor of the Topeka Daily Capital, described an elongated form. Dell's comment applies to every later case built on a famous name: “Their testimony establishes what they reported seeing. Their professional standing does not establish that the light belonged to an extraordinary aircraft.” In April the airship was over Iowa, Illinois, and Chicago's suburbs, and then over Texas.

The spread itself is part of the lesson. Each new town's report seemed to confirm the last. “Reports can reinforce one another without describing the same event,” Dell writes. A bright planet in one town, a hoax in another, and a sincere witness in a third can add up to what looks like one machine crossing the country. “The country had learned to look for airships. And suddenly, airships seemed to be everywhere.”

The cow that went up into the sky

The most famous single story came from Kansas. On April 23, 1897, the Farmer's Advocate of Yates Center printed a statement from Alexander Hamilton, a farmer near Le Roy and a former member of the state legislature. Late on the Monday night before, he said, a cigar-shaped airship about three hundred feet long had come down over his cow lot, with a lighted carriage beneath it and six strange beings inside. A red cable was looped around the neck of a heifer caught in his fence. He cut the wire, and the ship rose with the animal and disappeared. The next day, he said, a man three or four miles away found the hide, head, and legs in his field. His statement ended: “I don't know whether they are devils or angels, or what, but we all saw them, and my whole family saw the ship, and I don't want any more to do with them.” Printed beneath it was an affidavit, signed by prominent local men, saying Hamilton was an honest man.

It was a tall tale. In 1946 the Le Roy Reporter retold the story as a hoax, and the next year the Kansas Historical Quarterly listed it as “an airship hoax of 50 years ago.” In 1977 the UFO historian Jerome Clark published testimony from people who remembered the time: Hamilton belonged to a local liars' club, a group whose members competed to tell the most outrageous story, and the airship and the cow was his. By then it had been rediscovered and retold as an early case of alien cattle mutilation. Dell draws the moral plainly. “A respected witness can invent a story.” The affidavit vouched for Hamilton's character, not for the airship. And when the story was reread decades later, “An old hoax acquired new significance. Not because new evidence had emerged. But because the interpretation had changed.” Anyone comparing modern encounters with older reports, he writes, has to separate real testimony from stories known to be invented. “And there is no reason to manufacture a mystery where a perfectly good mystery already exists.”

The Martian of Aurora, Texas

On April 19, 1897, page 5 of The Dallas Morning News was crowded with airship reports from across North Texas. A man in Greenville said he was dazzled by its light. In Collin County it reportedly nearly hit the public school in Plano. A Judge Love of Waxahachie claimed to have spoken with the crew, who told him they came from the North Pole. The paper allowed that the stories might be true, or might prove that “Ananias and Sapphira were mere amateurs,” the couple in Acts 5 struck down for lying.

Among them was a short dispatch headed “A Windmill Demolishes It,” from S. E. Haydon of Aurora, a small town in Wise County northwest of Fort Worth, dated April 17. About six that morning, he wrote, “the early risers of Aurora were astonished at the sudden appearance of the airship which has been sailing through the country.” Its machinery seemed out of order. It was moving at only ten or twelve miles an hour and settling toward the ground. It passed over the public square, struck the tower of Judge Proctor's windmill, and went to pieces in an explosion, wrecking the windmill and water tank and the judge's flower garden. The pilot was the only one on board, and although his remains were badly disfigured, “enough of the original has been picked up to show that he was not an inhabitant of this world.” T. J. Weems, described as the local signal service officer and an authority on astronomy, gave his opinion that the pilot “was a native of the planet Mars.” Papers found on the body were “written in some unknown hieroglyphics, and can not be deciphered.” The metal resembled a mixture of aluminum and silver. The dispatch ended: “The pilot's funeral will take place at noon to-morrow.”

Dell points out what makes Aurora unusual within the wave. Almost every other airship story assumed a human inventor. This one “explicitly proposed an extraterrestrial origin,” with a crash, wreckage, a body, and a burial, about fifty years before Roswell. He also says what the record will bear. “But the evidence does not justify that conclusion.” The whole story rests on Haydon's dispatch. No wreckage has been authenticated, and no remains have been verified. Aurora itself, Dell notes, treats the event as part of its colorful local folklore. “The extraterrestrial explanation existed. It simply had not yet become the familiar default.”

The grave, the well, and the marker

The Morning News showed little interest in following up on its own extraordinary story. Aurora had been in decline for years. An outbreak of spotted fever from 1888 drove many people away, and when the railroad abandoned its plan to come through, most of the remaining residents moved two miles to Rhome. The Texas State Historical Association calls Haydon's piece “a fictional ‘news’ story” and says it “succeeded in causing a sensation because tales of UFOs near Fort Worth were already current.” In 1979, Etta Pegues, then 86, told Time: “Hayden wrote it as a joke and to bring interest to Aurora. The railroad bypassed us, and the town was dying.” She added, “Why, the judge never even had a windmill.”

The legend grew anyway. In 1973 investigators from the Mutual UFO Network found a grave marker in the Aurora Cemetery that seemed to show a crude craft, got readings with a metal detector, and asked to exhume. The cemetery association refused, and the stone later disappeared. A replacement marker was stolen too. In 2008 a cable television series opened a sealed well on the old Proctor land, found traces of aluminum in the water but no wreckage, and reported finding the base of an old windmill. The Texas Historical Commission marker outside the cemetery, put up in 1976, records the town's real history, its pioneer families and its epidemic, and then adds one sentence: “This site is also well known because of the legend that a spaceship crashed nearby in 1897 and the pilot, killed in the crash, was buried here.” The town's own history page now calls the pilot “Ned” and says he was given a Christian burial, a detail that is not in Haydon's dispatch. Visitors still leave coins and flowers at a boulder said to mark the grave. Dell's summary is exact: the crash site and burial story have become local legend, “But their historical existence as stories does not establish the event they describe.”

Was the 1897 airship mystery solved?

Not by a single answer, and probably not by any single cause. At the time, astronomers blamed bright planets and stars. The Dearborn Observatory's director pointed to Betelgeuse, and others named Venus, Jupiter, or Mars. Some sightings were balloons or kites carrying lanterns, sent up by pranksters. Many stories were newspaper inventions, written with a wink at the reader, in an age of sensational journalism. Thomas Edison was pressed hard enough by rumors that he was the inventor that he publicly denied it. A few writers have argued for real, secret airships. Michael Busby's Solving the 1897 Airship Mystery (2004) proposes three craft built by a group in Iowa, one of which, he concludes, came down at Aurora. J. Allan Danelek's The Great Airship of 1897 (2009) argues for one privately funded prototype. Neither has produced the machine.

Dell's own reading allows for all of it at once. “Some involved ordinary celestial objects. Some were misunderstandings. Some were deliberate fabrications. Others may have involved experimental aircraft or unusual atmospheric conditions. And some remain difficult to classify because the evidence is incomplete.”

Why the book places this before the flying saucer

The point of the chapter is not the airship. It is the pattern. Each era described strange things in the sky in the language of its own most advanced machines. In the 1890s they were dirigibles with propellers and searchlights. Before the First World War, Britain worried about German airships. In 1946 Sweden reported “ghost rockets.” Then, in 1947, came the flying saucer of Kenneth Arnold's sighting. Dell's list says it in five words: “Balloons. Airships. Aircraft. Rockets. Spacecraft.” And he asks the question that the rest of The Great Deception keeps pressing: “How much of the explanation comes from the observation? And how much comes from the technological imagination of the observer?”

There is a tempting answer, and Dell names it. Perhaps something deliberately took on the appearance each age expected, an airship in 1897 and a saucer in 1947. “If an unfamiliar intelligence were attempting to influence humanity, it might benefit from presenting itself in forms that appeared credible within a particular culture.” That idea sits close to the book's own argument about a spiritual deception. He does not let it run ahead of the evidence: “But the airship evidence does not establish that such a deception occurred.” Too many of the most spectacular airship stories were invented. The simpler explanation, that people were reading uncertain experiences through the expectations they already had, has to be heard first. “Historical research must begin with what people actually reported. Not with what modern investigators wish they had reported.”

That discipline cuts both ways, and it is the chapter's real warning for the present. The people of 1897 were not foolish for thinking a secret airship possible. “Their mistake, when a mistake occurred, was not that they considered an unfamiliar machine possible. It was that they sometimes treated the possibility as though it had already been established. Modern humanity may be vulnerable to the same error.” Today the ready-made frame is a visitor from another planet, and the book's larger question is what happens if that frame is offered to the world as settled fact. “The Great Airship Wave reminds us that an explanation can dominate an era without becoming an established fact.”

“The simple believeth every word: but the prudent man looketh well to his going.” Proverbs 14:15 (KJV)

Alexander Hamilton, inventing his story for a liars' club, still reached for the old categories when he wrote that he did not know whether the beings were “devils or angels.” Scripture warns that a generation can grow tired of what is true and go looking for something more exciting to believe. The airship wave shows how easily a good story outruns the evidence, and how long it can outlive the people who told it.

“And they shall turn away their ears from the truth, and shall be turned unto fables.” 2 Timothy 4:4 (KJV)

The flying-saucer age that followed is on Kenneth Arnold's 1947 UFO sighting, and the most famous crash story of all is on Roswell 1947. The idea that encounters may come from a realm alongside this one, rather than from another planet, is on the interdimensional theory of UFOs, and the Christian question is on Are UFOs demons? and UFOs and spiritual deception. Dell's shorter book, The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon, names “Roswell's wreckage” among its touchpoints and asks: “What if everything you thought you knew about UFOs was wrong?”

Common questions

What was the 1897 airship mystery?

A wave of newspaper reports, from November 1896 to the spring of 1897, of strange lighted airships over California and then across the Midwest and Texas. Witnesses usually assumed the craft had been built by a secret human inventor. No such machine or inventor was ever produced.

Was the 1897 airship mystery ever solved?

Not by one explanation. Bright planets and stars, balloons with lanterns, newspaper hoaxes, and tall tales account for many reports. Some writers argue that real experimental airships were flying, but none has been found. A number of reports remain hard to classify because the evidence is thin.

What happened in Aurora, Texas, in 1897?

On April 19, 1897, The Dallas Morning News printed a dispatch from S. E. Haydon saying an airship had hit Judge Proctor's windmill on April 17 and exploded, and that its pilot was “not an inhabitant of this world.” Historians and older residents later described the story as a hoax written to draw attention to a dying town.

Is there an alien buried in the Aurora Cemetery?

No remains have ever been exhumed or verified. The cemetery association has refused requests to dig, and the original grave marker was stolen. The state historical marker at the cemetery mentions the crash only as a legend.

Sources: S. E. Haydon, A Windmill Demolishes It, The Dallas Morning News, Apr. 19, 1897, p. 5 (image) · Texas State Historical Association, Author attempts to jump-start town with fictional UFO story (Texas Day by Day, Apr. 19) · Americana: Close Encounters of a Kind, Time (Mar. 12, 1979) · Texas Historical Commission, Aurora Cemetery marker (1976), via HMdb · Alex Macon, North Texas' Greatest UFO Story Lives On, D Magazine (June 10, 2021) · City of Aurora, Texas, History · Aurora, Texas, UFO incident (MUFON 1973, 2008 well, grave marker) · Roger L. Welsch, “This Mysterious Light Called an Airship”: Nebraska “Saucer” Sightings, 1897, Nebraska History 60 (1979) (PDF) · Kansas History as Published in the Press, Kansas Historical Quarterly 14:1 (Feb. 1947) · Jason Colavito, on Alexander Hamilton's 1897 statement and the liars' club · Mystery airship (Sacramento, Collins and Hart, explanations, Busby and Danelek) · Proverbs 14:15; 2 Timothy 4:4 (KJV)

Cover of The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell

Get the book

The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell. The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell traces the Great Airship Wave in its chapter “Before the Flying Saucer,” and asks how much of any sighting comes from the observation and how much from the expectations of the age. His shorter book is The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon.

More questions

Home · The Great Deception · Reading guide: Watchers in Scripture