The 1996 Varginha UFO incident: the creature three girls first called the devil

A rainy afternoon in a Brazilian coffee town, a crouching figure with red eyes, an Army inquiry, a disc-shaped water tower, and thirty years of testimony, some of it now withdrawn.

At about half past three on the afternoon of Saturday, January 20, 1996, three young women were on their way back from helping with a house move in the Jardim Andere neighborhood of Varginha, a city in the coffee country of southern Minas Gerais, Brazil. Kátia Xavier was 22. The sisters Liliane and Valquíria Silva were 16 and 14. Near a vacant lot on Rua Dr. Benevenuto Braz Vieira, they saw something crouched against a wall that none of them could name.

They ran. When the sisters reached home, Liliane told their mother she believed she had seen o capeta: the devil. Only later did a ufologist tell them they might have seen an extraterrestrial, and the “ET de Varginha” became one of the most famous UFO cases in the world, often called Brazil's Roswell. In The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon, David Dell asks whether the lights people chase are “glimpses of an interdimensional realm, home to the fallen angels of biblical lore.” In Varginha, the witnesses' own first word for the visitor was a spiritual one.

What the three young women saw

The descriptions they gave in 1996, on videotape later shown in a 2026 Globo documentary, are detailed. Valquíria said the thing looked at first “like an ox heart, but very big, shining, as if it had rubbed oil on its body.” The skin was dark brown and oily. The eyes were large and red, “two red balls” in one early report. Kátia remembered long fingers and oversized feet. When it turned its head, Liliane saw almost no face: if it had a nose and mouth, “it was just a little hole, a little slit.” On top of the large head were three bumps. “They weren't horns,” Liliane said. “They were lumps, three, two at the tips and one in the middle.” The figure seemed unsteady, and the women assumed it was hurt or sick.

Kátia froze while the sisters fled; they came back for her, and the three ran away crying. Their mother, Luísa Helena da Silva, went back to the spot with Kátia. There was nothing there, she said, but a footprint and a very strong smell, “not of an animal.” She never doubted her daughters. “They are telling the truth,” she said at the time. “I give you my word. A thousand times, if I have to.”

How one sighting became a crash story

The ufologist Ubirajara Rodrigues heard about the sighting and interviewed the women, and his colleague Vitório Pacaccini soon joined the investigation. Once the story was in the news, more reports followed. A farm couple, Oralina and Eurico de Freitas, said they had watched an object hover over their pasture for about forty minutes before dawn that month. Residents described Army trucks at the city's hospitals, Regional and Humanitas, and armed men keeping onlookers back. Rumors said firefighters had caught a creature that morning with a net, that another had been seen in a hospital, and that a body had been driven to the Army's sergeants' school in nearby Três Corações and on to Campinas. Animals died at the city zoo. A 23-year-old military police officer, Marco Eli Chereze, died some weeks later of an infection, and ufologists linked his death to a creature he was said to have handled.

A report on Globo's Sunday program Fantástico took the case national, and in June 1996 The Wall Street Journal carried the story abroad under the headline “Tale of Stinky Extraterrestrials Stirs Up UFO Crowd in Brazil.” In August 1996 Pacaccini and the writer Maxs Portes published Incidente em Varginha, which named soldiers and officers as having taken part in the capture and transport of the creature.

The Army inquiry and “Mudinho”

The book's claims about named soldiers led to a military police inquiry, opened in 1997 under the command of the Army's School of Sergeants. It took statements, checked vehicle logs and internal records, and heard from both ufologists. Every soldier named in the book testified and denied taking part, and the recorded routes and times of the trucks did not match the alleged transport. The trucks, the inquiry found, had been parked near a dealership for scheduled maintenance. Another explanation offered at the time, for the “small beings” said to have been seen in a hospital, was a couple with dwarfism who had come in for the birth of their baby.

As for the creature, the inquiry pointed to a local man, Luiz Antônio de Paula, who has an intellectual disability and was known in the neighborhood as “Mudinho,” the little mute, and was known for crouching in the streets. It had rained heavily that afternoon, with hail. “The more probable hypothesis,” the report concluded, “is that this citizen, probably dirty due to the rains and crouching next to a wall, was mistaken by three terrified girls for a ‘space creature’.” It also found that the officer Chereze had not taken part in any events on January 20; newspapers had reported that he died of an infection after surgery to remove a cyst. In January 2026 Brazil's Superior Military Court, which holds the records, published details from the inquiry.

The women have always rejected the Mudinho answer. “We had known him since we were little, without a shadow of a doubt,” Valquíria said. Liliane said the same: anyone walking through Jardim Andere could see him crouched there. “We knew him. It wasn't Mudinho.” Skeptics such as Brian Dunning of Skeptoid answer that the women's earliest statements said they did not know the man, and that the story has grown over the years.

Thirty years later: the retractions

The case reached its thirtieth anniversary in January 2026 with a three-part Globo and EPTV documentary series, O Mistério de Varginha, directed by Ricardo Calil and Paulo Gonçalves. It changed the record in several ways.

An earlier documentary, James Fox's Moment of Contact (2022), had presented Varginha as a true case of alien visitation. The town has made its own peace with the story: spaceship-shaped bus shelters, an ET memorial museum, and a water tower about twenty meters tall topped with a flying saucer. On January 20, 2026, Varginha marked the thirtieth anniversary with an open day at the memorial.

What Varginha shows

Strip away the trucks, the tapes, and the hospital rumors, and what remains is what was there at the start: three young women who saw something they could not explain and have never changed their account. Nearly everything added to the story afterward, the capture, the convoy, the body taken to Campinas, has either been withdrawn by the person who told it or rests on testimony that cannot be checked.

In The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory, David Dell examines an earlier Brazilian case, the frightening lights over Colares in 1977, and reaches a verdict on the Air Force files there that fits Varginha's Army files as well: “These records establish that the Brazilian military took the reports seriously enough to conduct a formal inquiry. They do not establish that extraterrestrial entities were responsible.” In the same chapter, writing about an encounter that an earlier age would have described as enchantment and a modern one as alien technology, he notes: “The experience might have been misperceived in either case. But the interpretations would be radically different.”

A spiritual reading of Varginha

That is the heart of Varginha. The interpretation came in two layers. The first came from the witnesses themselves, three frightened young women who reached for the oldest category they had and called the creature a devil. The second came from outside, from a researcher who told them that ufology believes such beings come from other planets, and who now calls that his great mistake. Thirty years of books, films, and tourism were built on the second layer.

The Watchers Among Us starts from the first. It describes a presence that has been alongside us all along, “watching, waiting, deceiving,” and calls itself not “a tale of invasion” but “a reckoning with the unseen, a call to peel back the mask and face what's been whispering since the beginning.” If the beings behind the strangest encounters are spiritual, the mask is the alien label itself, and Varginha is a case where the witnesses' first reading and the label later given to them can be set side by side. Scripture names the real contest plainly.

“For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places.” Ephesians 6:12 (KJV)

Varginha also shows how much damage a false witness can do on any side of such a question. Testimony that was coached or bought did not merely mislead a public. It followed three women for thirty years, through mockery and doubt that their own story never earned.

“A false witness shall not be unpunished, and he that speaketh lies shall not escape.” Proverbs 19:5 (KJV)

The book asks of the visitors: “Are they testing us? Shaping us?” Whatever crouched by the wall in Jardim Andere, the story that grew around it has shaped a city, its witnesses, and millions of people who now expect any such encounter to end in a hangar or a laboratory. The question of what the women saw is still open. The question of what to call it was answered first by the witnesses, and only later by the experts.

Another case in which children took the visitors for evil spirits is on the 1994 Ariel School UFO encounter. The crash story that set the pattern for Varginha is on Roswell 1947, and Pennsylvania's version, with its own soldiers and missing evidence, is on the 1965 Kecksburg UFO incident. Small, frightening beings at a farmhouse door are on the 1955 Kelly-Hopkinsville encounter. The view that some reports come from a realm alongside this one is on the interdimensional theory of UFOs, and the Christian question is on Are UFOs demons?

Common questions

What happened in Varginha in 1996?

On January 20, 1996, three young women in Varginha, Minas Gerais, Brazil, said they saw a creature with oily brown skin, red eyes, and three bumps on its head crouched by a wall. Rumors followed of a crashed craft, creatures captured by firefighters and the Army, and bodies taken to hospitals. An Army inquiry concluded that nothing of the kind took place.

What did the Varginha creature look like?

The witnesses described a figure that was not very tall, with shiny, oily dark brown skin, a large head with three bumps on top, large red eyes, almost no nose or mouth, long fingers, and oversized feet. It seemed unsteady, as if injured.

Was the Varginha UFO incident debunked?

The Brazilian Army's 1997 inquiry concluded the women saw a local man known as Mudinho and that the military movements were routine. In 2026 the first investigator said he no longer believes the story, and two of three military witnesses said their accounts were invented. The three women still stand by what they saw.

Did the Varginha witnesses think it was an alien?

Not at first. Liliane Silva told her mother she thought she had seen the devil. The idea that it was an extraterrestrial came later, from a ufologist, who in 2026 called that suggestion his great mistake.

Sources: Varginha UFO incident (overview, time and street, “two red balls,” inquiry, tourism, books and films) · Incidente de Varginha (shortcut through the lot, the farm couple's sighting), Wikipédia (in Portuguese) · Brian Dunning, Brazil's Roswell: The Varginha UFO, Skeptoid #853 (Oct. 11, 2022) · ET de Varginha, 30 anos: o que se sabe e o que nunca foi explicado sobre o caso, g1 Sul de Minas (Jan. 20, 2026) · ‘Eu vou ser sempre a menina que viu o ET’: vídeos inéditos revelam a origem do caso, g1 (Jan. 7, 2026) · De ‘casal de anões’ a ‘mudinho’: como autoridades contestaram suposta aparição, g1 (Jan. 8, 2026) · Ufólogo que ajudou a projetar caso ET de Varginha diz que história não existiu, g1 (Jan. 8, 2026) · Caso Varginha 30 anos depois: ex-militar diz que inventou relato, g1 (Jan. 8, 2026) · Médico afirma que colega filmou cirurgia em ‘ser estranho’, g1 (Jan. 6, 2026) · Como vivem as ‘meninas’ que dizem ter visto ET, g1 (Jan. 9, 2026) · STM divulga dados de inquérito sobre ET de Varginha, Estadão (Jan. 6, 2026) · ET de Varginha completa 30 anos e caso continua recebendo novidades, Estadão/TecMundo (Jan. 22, 2026) · Memorial do ET: 30 anos dos acontecimentos de Varginha, Prefeitura de Varginha (Jan. 19, 2026) · Ephesians 6:12; Proverbs 19:5 (KJV)

Cover of The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell

Get the book

The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell. Its chapter “The Visitors Who Behaved Like Ghosts” weighs the Brazilian Air Force files on the Colares lights of 1977 and separates what military records establish from the more dramatic stories told in later decades. A presence “watching, waiting, deceiving” is the subject of David Dell's shorter book, The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon.

More questions

Home · The Great Deception · Reading guide: Watchers in Scripture