The O'Hare UFO sighting of 2006: the disc over Gate C17, the hole in the clouds, and the FAA tapes
A ramp worker who looked straight up, two mechanics in an empty 777, a call to a control tower that saw nothing, an FAA answer about airport lights on a day the lights were still off, and a photo that turned out to be a fake.
On Tuesday, November 7, 2006, a little after four in the afternoon, a United Airlines ramp worker was helping push back a Boeing 737 from Gate C17 at Chicago's O'Hare International Airport. The plane was United flight 446, due out for Charlotte, North Carolina. He was standing beside the nose of the jet with his headset plugged in when, in the words of the investigators who later interviewed him, he “was compelled to look straight up for some reason and was startled to see the craft hovering silently.”
What he saw, and what as many as a dozen United employees said they saw over the next few minutes, was a dark gray, sharply outlined object hanging under the overcast above Concourse C. It made no sound and showed no lights. Some said it spun like a Frisbee; others said it did not turn at all. Then, by their account, it shot up through the cloud deck and left a clean, round gap behind it. “It was like somebody punched a hole in the sky,” one employee told the Chicago Tribune.
Almost nobody outside the airline heard about it for nearly two months. When the Tribune's transportation reporter, Jon Hilkevitch, broke the story on New Year's Day 2007, it drew more than a million page views within days. An editor at the paper's website said it “pretty much blows anything else out of the water as far as I can recall.”
The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon by David Dell dares readers “to rethink the lights—and the shadows they cast.” O'Hare is an odd case to try that on, because it had no lights at all: a dark gray shape in daylight, over what the Tribune called the world's second-busiest airport, watched by people whose job is watching aircraft.
What did the witnesses see at O'Hare?
The fullest record of the witnesses is a 2007 report by the National Aviation Reporting Center on Anomalous Phenomena (NARCAP), a private group concerned with aviation safety. Its lead author was Richard F. Haines, a former chief of the Space Human Factors Office at NASA's Ames Research Center. NARCAP's team interviewed witnesses, obtained the FAA's tower recordings, log and radar data under the Freedom of Information Act, and published the results as Technical Report 10.
- The ramp worker at C17. He put the object 500 to 1,000 feet directly above his gate, round and rotating “pretty fast,” about the size of a quarter held at arm's length. He radioed the airline's operations center, told the cockpit crew of his 737, and estimated that ten to fifteen people saw it. He said it “shot off into the clouds” about two minutes after he first noticed it.
- Two mechanics in an empty 777. Taxiing an empty jet toward United's maintenance hangar, they heard talk on the company frequency of “a circle or disc shapped [sic] object hovering over gate” and leaned forward to look. One of them told NARCAP it was stationary, hazy on the bottom and ends but clearer on top, and never changed brightness, color or shape in the thirty seconds to a minute he watched it. “I'll tell you definitely, it's not an airplane as we know it.”
- A manager in Concourse B. He ran outside after hearing the report on an internal airline radio frequency. “I knew no one would make a false call like that,” he told the Tribune. “But if somebody was bouncing a weather balloon or something else over O'Hare, we had to stop it because it was in very close proximity to our flight operations.”
- A woman in the parking lot. About a mile away, at the edge of the International Terminal parking lot, she said she watched it for ten to fourteen minutes with a group of about seven people. “One fellow had a digital camera. He was taking many pictures.”
The accounts do not all agree, which is normal for a sighting seen from different places by people who were busy doing other things. Size estimates in the Tribune ran from 6 to 24 feet across; NARCAP, working from one witness's angle and the height of the cloud base, put it at about 22 to 88 feet. Height guesses ran from 500 to 1,800 feet, and NARCAP pointed out that the two men standing directly underneath gave the lowest figures from the worst vantage point. Timings differ too: the mechanics placed their sighting somewhere between about 3:57 and 4:18 p.m., the ramp worker at about 4:30, and another witness had it vanish at about 4:33. NARCAP concluded that the object was over the airport for at least ten minutes, though no one person watched it that long.
What happened when United called the tower?
From United's ramp tower, an employee named Sue called the FAA control tower to ask whether controllers could see it. The tower's certified Daily Record of Facility Operation for that day, released to NARCAP, has the entry: “SUE FROM UNITED RAMP TOWER CALLED TO INQUIRE IF WE HAD SEEN A FLYING DISC OVER THE UNITED TERMINAL IN THE VICINITY OF GATE C17 AT ABOUT ONE THOUSAND FEET. I REPLIED THAT WE HAD NOT.” It is logged at 4:45 p.m. A second line closes the matter at 5:03.
No controller saw the object. NARCAP later worked out one reason: from the tower cab, the roof overhang and canted windows cut off the view upward, and a standing controller could not have seen an object over C17 higher than about 1,440 feet. The ground-control tapes contain one remark about it, a controller telling a flight to “use caution for the, ah UFO,” and NARCAP could not reconcile that remark's time stamp with the witnesses' own timings.
Radar showed nothing either. FAA spokeswoman Elizabeth Isham Cory told the Tribune that “a preliminary check of radar found nothing out of the ordinary,” and NARCAP's own review of the primary radar data the FAA supplied found no return at that spot. Its radar analyst, Martin Shough, flagged a single weather-radar echo near the cloud base within minutes of the sighting, but the report says technical considerations “cast some doubt on this possibility.”
Why did United and the FAA say nothing?
Both first told the Tribune they had no information. “There's nothing in the duty manager log, which is used to report unusual incidents,” said United spokeswoman Megan McCarthy. “I checked around. There's no record of anything.” Yet some employees told the paper that United officials had asked them to write reports and draw pictures of what they saw, and advised them not to talk about it. The FAA changed its answer after the Tribune filed a Freedom of Information Act request: an internal review of the tapes turned up the United supervisor's call to the tower.
The FAA then gave its explanation and said it would not investigate further. “Our theory on this is that it was a weather phenomenon,” Cory said. “That night was a perfect atmospheric condition in terms of low [cloud] ceiling and a lot of airport lights. When the lights shine up into the clouds, sometimes you can see funny things. That's our take on it.” In the tower, controller and union official Craig Burzych made a joke of it: “To fly 7 million light years to O'Hare and then have to turn around and go home because your gate was occupied is simply unacceptable.”
Was it a hole-punch cloud?
The FAA's account has an obvious gap: it was not night. The sighting came in daylight, shortly before sunset, and NARCAP reported that the airport's ramp lights had not yet been switched on. One of the mechanics said that was why the object was so easy to see; once the floodlights are on, “it makes it much harder to see things in the sky around the terminal.”
The better-known natural explanation came later. In 2013 Mark Hammergren, an astronomer at Chicago's Adler Planetarium, told the Tribune that conditions that day were right for a “hole-punch cloud,” also called a fallstreak hole: “It's something that occurs when a propeller or jet airplane passes through when you have uniform cloud cover and the temperature is right near the freezing point. They make liquid water droplets freeze and a hazy disc of ice crystals descends from a hole, and it looks like a perfect hole punched in the cloud.” Hole-punch clouds are real, and a hazy disc under a round gap is not far from some of the descriptions.
The weather record is the difficulty. O'Hare's observations that afternoon show 12 °C (about 54 °F) at the surface and an overcast at about 1,700 to 1,900 feet, and the balloon sounding NARCAP used, from Davenport, Iowa, that evening, shows air around 10 °C at that height. That is nowhere near freezing. NARCAP's cloud analysts rejected a fallstreak hole for that reason and went much further: they argued that only a sudden burst of heat could have cleared the cloud so cleanly, and concluded that the hole “cannot be explained by either conventional weather phenomena or conventional aerospace craft.” NARCAP is a private group, and the FAA never examined the question at all.
Is there a photo of the O'Hare UFO?
Not a confirmed one. Witnesses said people were taking pictures, and the United ramp tower told the FAA tower that “someone got a picture of it,” but no authenticated photo or video has ever been published. Most of the images that circulated online were shown to be fakes. NARCAP traced one to an ordinary photograph of the O'Hare terminals that had been mirror-reversed with a disc pasted in. A primary witness pointed out that it showed MD-80s, which United no longer flew, and that the disc was “much too big, is in the wrong place, and is hazy.” The report counted at least a dozen fraudulent claims involving hoaxed photographs of the case.
Why the O'Hare case still matters
O'Hare is the case researchers reach for when the subject is aviation safety rather than aliens. Hilkevitch said his sources “were very concerned from the standpoint of airport safety,” and that none of them were “flying off the handle with crazy conspiracy theories.” NARCAP's conclusion was about safety too: “Anytime an airborne object can hover for several minutes over a busy airport but not be registered on radar or seen visually from the control tower, constitutes a potential threat to flight safety.” Mark Rodeghier of the Chicago-based Center for UFO Studies put it more bluntly to the Tribune in 2013: “But how can you not worry about something hovering over an airport after 9/11? It doesn't make sense.”
The same complaint, that crews see things the official record does not catch, runs through the congressional hearings of recent years: the UAP hearings explained.
A shape in the sky and the question behind it
One line in the Tribune story is easy to miss. A co-worker said one United employee was emotionally shaken by the sighting and “experienced some religious issues” over it. That is not a strange reaction. A silent thing that hangs over a crowded airport, does not show on radar, and leaves through the ceiling of the sky does not feel like an aircraft, and people reach for older words.
David Dell's longer book, The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory, draws a line that fits O'Hare well. In its chapter “Machines That Break the Rules” it says: “There is an important difference between observing an object and determining the nature of the intelligence, if any, associated with it.” The people at Gate C17 observed. What they observed is a separate question, and Scripture asks believers to keep the two apart:
“Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.” 1 John 4:1 (KJV)
The Watchers Among Us takes the next step. It treats the lights we chase as “glimpses of an interdimensional realm, home to the fallen angels of biblical lore,” and speaks of “a presence that's been alongside us all along—watching, waiting, deceiving.” An object seen plainly by a dozen trained people that leaves no confirmed radar track, no authenticated photograph and almost no official record is a strange kind of visitor. For the book's question, “Are they testing us? Shaping us?”, it is a fitting one.
Fourteen months later, in Texas, dozens of witnesses and the official answer pulled in different directions again: the Stephenville UFO sightings of 2008. Radar and visual reports over an American city first collided in the 1952 Washington, D.C. UFO flap, and a Navy pilot's encounter with a white object off California is on the Nimitz “Tic Tac”. A mass sighting argued over as aircraft and flares is the Phoenix Lights (1997). The view that some of these objects are not machines at all is on the interdimensional theory of UFOs, and the Christian question is on Are UFOs demons? A Christian view.
Common questions
When was the O'Hare UFO sighting?
Tuesday, November 7, 2006, at roughly 4:15 to 4:30 p.m. Central time, over United Airlines' Gate C17 in Concourse C at Chicago O'Hare. The public first heard of it in the Chicago Tribune on January 1, 2007.
Did the O'Hare UFO show up on radar?
No. The FAA said a preliminary check of radar found nothing out of the ordinary, and NARCAP's review of the FAA's primary radar data found no return over Gate C17. One possible weather-radar echo near the cloud base remains doubtful.
What did the FAA say about the O'Hare UFO?
After first saying it had no information, the FAA confirmed a United supervisor's call to the tower, said no controller saw the object, called it a “weather phenomenon” involving low cloud and airport lights, and declined to investigate.
Is there a real photo of the O'Hare UFO?
No authenticated photo or video has been published. NARCAP showed that at least one widely shared image was a reversed stock photo of the terminals with a disc added, and counted at least a dozen hoaxed photo claims.
Was the O'Hare UFO a hole-punch cloud?
Adler Planetarium astronomer Mark Hammergren said conditions were right for one. NARCAP rejected the idea because the cloud layer was well above freezing that afternoon, with about 12 °C at the surface.
Sources: Jon Hilkevitch, In the sky! A bird? A plane? A ... UFO?, Chicago Tribune (Jan. 1, 2007) · Richard F. Haines et al., Report of an Unidentified Aerial Phenomenon and its Safety Implications at O'Hare International Airport on November 7, 2006, NARCAP Technical Report 10 (rev. July 24, 2007) · NARCAP technical reports list · Edward B. Colby, Chi Trib Readers Seem to Believe, Columbia Journalism Review (Jan. 5, 2007) · O'Hare UFO sighting in 2006 one of the most famous reported, Chicago Tribune (Mar. 20, 2013) · 1 John 4:1 (KJV)
