The Brookings Report of 1960: what NASA's study actually said about extraterrestrial life

A 1960 study for NASA, two pages on the discovery of life beyond Earth, one sentence about withholding it from the public, one footnote that mentions UFOs, and a long afterlife in cover-up lore.

The Brookings Report is the nickname of a study the Brookings Institution delivered to NASA in December 1960, Proposed Studies on the Implications of Peaceful Space Activities for Human Affairs. Almost all of it is about satellites, weather forecasting, industry and foreign policy. It is famous for something else: about two pages near the end on what might happen if humanity discovered intelligent life beyond Earth, including a question about whether such news might be “presented to or withheld from the public.”

That one line is now widely quoted as proof that NASA planned to hide aliens. The report itself is public, and it is more interesting than the legend. The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell opens its chapter “One World Under a New Sky” with this report, because it asked, in 1960, the question that matters most about any future announcement from the sky: who gets to explain it?

What was the Brookings Report?

NASA was barely two years old. The Soviet Union had launched Sputnik in 1957, NASA was founded in 1958, and no human being had yet flown in space. NASA's Committee on Long-Range Studies asked the Brookings Institution, a Washington research organization, to map the social science questions the space program would raise. The work was led by Donald N. Michael, a social psychologist with a background in the natural sciences, with seven collaborators: Jack Baranson, Raymond A. Bauer, Richard L. Meier, Aaron B. Nadel, Herbert A. Shepard, Herbert E. Striner and Christopher Wright.

The report is dated December 1960. Its chapters cover the organization of a NASA social science research unit, communications satellites, a space-based weather system, technological by-products, government operations, space industries, international affairs and foreign policy, and attitudes and values. It was submitted to the House Committee on Science and Astronautics on April 18, 1961, six days after Yuri Gagarin became the first man in space, and the committee reprinted it as a committee print.

It was not a secret document, and it did not announce anything. It was a list of proposed studies, with reasons for each.

What did the Brookings Report say about aliens?

The passage sits in the “Attitudes and Values” chapter under the heading “The implications of a discovery of extraterrestrial life.” It begins with radio astronomy, not flying saucers. The authors note that recent publicity about efforts to detect extraterrestrial messages by radio telescope had made speculation about such a discovery respectable. Then they set a timetable:

“While face-to-face meetings with it will not occur within the next twenty years (unless its technology is more advanced than ours, qualifying it to visit earth), artifacts left at some point in time by these life forms might possibly be discovered through our space activities on the Moon, Mars, or Venus.”

The most likely contact, they thought, would be by radio. Reactions would depend on each person's “cultural, religious, and social background,” and on how leaders behaved. “The discovery would certainly be front-page news everywhere.” Beyond that, the authors refused to promise a single outcome:

“The knowledge that life existed in other parts of the universe might lead to a greater unity of men on earth, based on the ‘oneness’ of man or on the age-old assumption that any stranger is threatening.”

Because radio messages between stars would take years, they thought the fact of other beings “might become simply one of the facts of life but probably not one calling for action.” Then comes the passage with the darkest tone:

“Anthropological files contain many examples of societies, sure of their place in the universe, which have disintegrated when they have had to associate with previously unfamiliar societies espousing different ideas and different life ways; others that survived such an experience usually did so by paying the price of changes in values and attitudes and behavior.”

Because the consequences were unpredictable, the report recommended two kinds of research: continuing studies of how people understand and feel about the possibility of intelligent extraterrestrial life, and historical studies of how peoples and their leaders behave “when confronted with dramatic and unfamiliar events or social pressures.”

“Withheld from the public”: what the famous line says

The line everyone quotes is the last part of that second recommendation. The report lists the questions such historical studies might try to answer:

“How might such information, under what circumstances, be presented to or withheld from the public for what ends? What might be the role of the discovering scientists and other decision makers regarding release of the fact of discovery?”

Those two sentences are the report's entire treatment of secrecy. They are framed as research questions. The report does not recommend withholding anything, does not say anything had been found, and takes no position on whether a cover-up would be wise. Writing in 1997, Keith Woodard made the same point: the report raised the possibility of withholding information “but took no position on its advisability.”

David Dell reads it the same way. The report, he writes, “was a proposal for further research into possible social consequences. The authors were asking questions, not announcing a secret policy.” Asking how news should be released is what any planner does before a crisis. It is not evidence that the news exists.

Does the Brookings Report mention UFOs?

Once, in a footnote. The report's notes were issued as a separate volume, and note 37, attached to the recommendation about historical studies, reads: “Such studies would include historical reactions to hoaxes, psychic manifestations, unidentified flying objects, etc.” It names Hadley Cantril's Invasion from Mars (1940), the study of the panic around Orson Welles's War of the Worlds broadcast, as a useful if limited guide, and adds a line about societies that met technologically advanced ones: “Some thrived, some endured, and some died.”

So the authors filed UFOs with hoaxes and psychic claims, as examples of how the public reacts to startling reports, not as possible evidence of visitors. How much the 1938 panic itself was exaggerated is discussed on the alien false-flag theory.

The footnote about religion

The other note that draws attention is note 34. It says that “the positions of the major American religious denominations, the Christian sects, and the Eastern religions on the matter of extraterrestrial life need elucidation,” and then quotes correspondence from the anthropologist Rhoda Métraux, drawn from her field work in Montserrat and Haiti: “The Fundamentalist (and anti-science) sects are growing apace around the world.” She expected the discovery of other life to be electrifying for those groups, and urged studies of their churches and missions. The same note goes on to say that finding plant life or some subhuman intelligence on Mars or Venus might, once the novelty wore off, change people's perspectives no more than the discovery of the coelacanth or the panda had, but “If super intelligence is discovered, the results become quite unpredictable,” and it records the speculation that scientists and engineers “might be the most devastated by the discovery of relatively superior creatures.”

Read in full, the note does not predict that religion would collapse. It says believers' reactions had not been studied and should be. Christians had already thought about the heavens and humanity's smallness under them for a very long time. David's response to the night sky was not crisis but worship:

“When I consider thy heavens, the work of thy fingers, the moon and the stars, which thou hast ordained; What is man, that thou art mindful of him? and the son of man, that thou visitest him?” Psalm 8:3–4 (KJV)

What Scripture does and does not say about life elsewhere is on What does the Bible say about aliens?

How a NASA study became cover-up lore

The report was news from the start. On December 15, 1960, a UPI story in The New York Times ran under the headline “Mankind Is Warned to Prepare for Discovery of Life in Space.” NICAP's newsletter, The U.F.O. Investigator, covered it under “Space-life Report Could Be Shock.” Decades later it resurfaced in a different role. A 1993 Washington Times front-page story, “Mars watchers see extraterrestrial cover-up,” brought it up, and Richard C. Hoagland argued that by laying out plausible motives for suppressing a discovery, the report furnishes evidence of a cover-up of intelligent life already found.

Dell's chapter names the move plainly. Some writers took the passage as evidence that NASA had been preparing to conceal discoveries, others as proof of official awareness that alien contact could reshape society, “But the document did not establish either conclusion.” The same pattern runs through Project Blue Beam and the reading of Reagan's 1987 U.N. analogy as a plan: a real document, a real sentence, and a conclusion the sentence does not carry.

What David Dell takes from it

Dell does not dismiss the report. He keeps one observation from it as “profoundly important”: “The social consequences of discovering another intelligence might depend less upon the discovery itself than upon how humanity interprets it.” A radio signal from a distant star would be a matter for astronomy. “A claim that the signal's creators possessed the true explanation of human origins would be something entirely different.”

That is where the book's argument about deception lives. Not necessarily, Dell writes, “in the appearance of an unfamiliar intelligence. But in the struggle to decide who has the authority to explain it.” Later in the chapter he returns to the report and adds: “There is no reason to assume that a genuine extraterrestrial civilization would automatically become humanity's new source of authority.”

For a Christian reader, that line has an old foundation. Paul did not grant authority to a messenger because of where it came from:

“But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed.” Galatians 1:8 (KJV)

The same test applies to an official announcement (see Is UFO disclosure a deception?) and to the visitors who already arrive with sermons (see alien contactees and Jesus). The Brookings authors asked how leaders would handle the news. Dell's question goes one step further: who would be telling the story, and would it be true?

Where to read the Brookings Report

The full report is on NASA's Technical Reports Server as document 19640053196 (NASA-CR-55643). The notes, including notes 34 and 37, are a separate NTRS document, 19640053194 (NASA-CR-55640). The extraterrestrial-life passage is near the end of the main report, in the “Attitudes and Values” chapter, just before the section on man in space. Both scans are linked in the sources below.

Common questions

Did the Brookings Report say NASA should hide evidence of aliens?

No. It listed “How might such information, under what circumstances, be presented to or withheld from the public for what ends?” as a question for future research. It did not recommend secrecy or claim any discovery.

Who wrote the Brookings Report?

A Brookings Institution team led by social psychologist Donald N. Michael, with seven collaborators, for NASA's Committee on Long-Range Studies. It is dated December 1960.

Does the Brookings Report mention UFOs?

Only in note 37, which suggests studying public reactions to “hoaxes, psychic manifestations, unidentified flying objects, etc.”

What did the Brookings Report say about religion?

Note 34 said the positions of religious groups on extraterrestrial life needed study, and quoted an anthropologist's view that the discovery would be electrifying for fundamentalist sects. It did not predict the end of religion.

Sources: Donald N. Michael et al., Proposed Studies on the Implications of Peaceful Space Activities for Human Affairs, Brookings Institution for NASA (Dec. 1960), NTRS 19640053196 · Footnotes volume, NTRS 19640053194 · Fred Dews, The Advice Brookings Gave NASA about the Space Program in 1960, Brookings (May 12, 2014) · Brookings Report (submission, press coverage, Hoagland, Woodard) · Richard C. Hoagland · Rhoda Métraux · Psalm 8:3–4; Galatians 1:8 (KJV)

Cover of The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell

Get the book

The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell. Its chapter “One World Under a New Sky” opens with the Brookings study and asks the question the report raised in 1960: when news of another intelligence arrives, who has the authority to explain it? His shorter book is The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon.

More questions

Home · The Great Deception · Reading guide: Watchers in Scripture