The Stephenville UFO sightings of 2008: the lights over Erath County, the F-16s, and the radar data

A pilot by a brush fire, a constable in his front yard, a denial from the air base, a correction two weeks later, an FAA email that had the jets on record all along, and a MUFON radar study that pointed toward the president's ranch.

On the evening of Tuesday, January 8, 2008, Steve Allen and a group of friends were warming themselves around a fire of brush and debris on a hilltop near Selden, just south of Stephenville, Texas. Allen, 50, owned a local trucking company and held a pilot's license. He told the Los Angeles Times that they first saw a set of brilliant white lights coming from the east that looked like the corners of something a mile long and half a mile wide. “They came within a mile of us,” he said. “It flipped us all out.”

The lights stopped, rearranged themselves into an arch “shaped like the top of a football,” then into two vertical lines of randomly flashing lights, and burst into a dirty white flame. “It looked like something firing up, like a blowtorch,” Allen said. “It simply vanished.” About ten minutes later the lights came back from the opposite direction, and this time, Allen was certain, two military jets were close behind them. He told NPR the thing was “bigger than a Wal-Mart” and crossed in seconds a stretch of sky that takes him twenty minutes to fly in his Cessna.

Within two weeks Stephenville, a ranch town in the dairy country about 70 miles southwest of Fort Worth, was on Larry King Live, Good Morning America, NPR and CNN. The Los Angeles Times called it the biggest mass UFO sighting since the Phoenix Lights of 1997, and it is still argued over: one camp says ten fighter jets explain it, the other says the radar shows something the Air Force never explained.

The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon by David Dell asks a question that fits Stephenville better than most cases: “What if everything you thought you knew about UFOs was wrong?” Here it cuts both ways.

What did the witnesses see?

Constable Lee Roy Gaitan, then 44, saw his part of it from home. He told the Los Angeles Times he saw brilliant red orbs hovering in the sky and called his family outside. His wife stayed on the couch, sure it was an airplane. His 8-year-old son Ryan went out to the yard and said, “That's a UFO.” Gaitan told NPR the red glow reminded him of pictures of an erupting volcano and that the object hung about 3,000 feet up. With an election coming, he kept quiet at first: “People would say, ‘Hey, this guy is nuts. He's crazy.’”

Within days the Stephenville Empire-Tribune ran a front-page story by Angelia Joiner, an education reporter who took Allen's call: “Possible UFO Sighting – Four area residents witness mysterious objects.” More people came forward once they saw they were not alone. The paper put the count at about 40 witnesses, some of whom admitted it only after others had spoken.

The accounts did not all match, which is normal for a sighting spread over hours and miles. Allen described white lights, a reconfiguring shape and a flame. Gaitan described red orbs. Others described a large, silent object, very bright, sometimes stationary and sometimes moving at enormous speed. Several said military jets were in the sky with it.

The Air Force said no jets were flying

That last detail made the first official answer a problem. When Joiner checked, the 301st Fighter Wing at Naval Air Station Fort Worth Joint Reserve Base, the old Carswell field, said no aircraft had been near Stephenville when the lights were first seen. NPR reported that military officials passed the sighting off as an optical illusion, most likely sunlight reflecting off two airliners, and that the nearby base said its fighter pilots had not chased anything that night.

So the town had witnesses who said they saw jets and a base that said there were none. The theories ran ahead of the facts. The Times heard that the object was headed for a nearby nuclear plant to refuel, or looking for President George W. Bush at his ranch in Crawford, about an hour's drive away. T-shirts reading “Alien Capital of the World” were rushed into production. The high school science club sold its own, “Erath County – the New Roswell,” and raised $7,000 for college scholarships. By mid-February Gaitan had given more than 100 interviews.

The FAA email and the January 23 correction

The record that settled the jet question was not sitting in a classified file. On January 17, 2008, James McGaha, a retired Air Force major and pilot who directs the Grasslands Observatory in Arizona, emailed an FAA regional communications office with six questions about traffic around Stephenville between 5:30 and 7 p.m. on January 8, among them whether the Fort Worth center had been controlling any aircraft in the Brownwood Military Operations Areas, training airspace near the town. The next morning, at 8:33 a.m. on January 18, an FAA quality-assurance manager at the Fort Worth Air Route Traffic Control Center answered internally:

“During the period in question we had several aircraft that were in the vicinity of Stephenville. … We had 4 F16s enter Brownwood MOA/ATCAA at 1817. They were just east of Stephenville … and worked the south area …. At 1826 4 more F16s entered the same spot and worked the north area. They split into two flight of two and exited at 1854 and 1858.”

The email chain was later released under the Freedom of Information Act to John Greenewald of The Black Vault. Eight F-16s, then, were in training airspace beside Stephenville from 6:17 to 6:58 p.m., the window in which the first witnesses reported their lights.

On Wednesday, January 23, the Air Force Reserve put out a correction. “In the interest of public awareness, Air Force Reserve Command Public Affairs realized an error was made regarding the reported training activity of military aircraft,” the release said. Ten F-16s of the 457th Fighter Squadron had been on a night training mission in the Brownwood area between 6 and 8 p.m. on January 8. A spokesman, Karl Lewis, told CNN the error came from an internal communications problem between offices at the base.

F-16s and flares: the skeptical explanation

McGaha's case, set out with Joe Nickell in the Skeptical Inquirer in 2015, is that the witnesses saw the F-16s doing what fighters do in a training area at night. The jets were flying air-combat drills and dropping countermeasure flares, decoys used to draw off heat-seeking missiles. In afterburner, a fighter throws a burst of flame visible from a long way off. McGaha cited the pilot of a military helicopter who was flying that night: “I saw multiple military aircraft, with some dropping flares, in the area of the Brownwood 1 MOA.” Some MUFON witnesses, he noted, described lights “similar to the intensity of burning magnesium,” and some said they saw flares fall from aircraft.

On this reading the “mile-long object” is the mind joining separate lights into one shape, the same mechanism skeptics propose for the Phoenix Lights and the Hudson Valley boomerang. McGaha's conclusion was blunt: “The untrained witnesses/observers were seeing nothing more than F-16s and flares. Stephenville is nothing more than connecting ‘lights in the sky’ to form a very large mysterious object, an object that many that night thought was from another world. But nothing otherworldly happened around Stephenville on January 8, 2008.”

The MUFON radar data

The Mutual UFO Network took the opposite view, and it brought data. Its investigators began interviewing witnesses in nearby Dublin on January 19 and collected seventeen reports of sightings on January 8, eight with enough detail to fix a time and direction. The witnesses included a constable, a chief of police, a private pilot and a former air traffic controller. Glen Schulze, an electrical engineer with a long career in radar recording, and Robert Powell, MUFON's director of research, filed ten Freedom of Information requests. The FAA sent 2.8 million radar returns from five radar sites covering 4 to 8 p.m. The base supplied the 457th's logbook, most of it blacked out.

Their report, Stephenville Lights: A Comprehensive Radar and Witness Report Study, released in July 2008, made several claims:

The report was also candid about what radar cannot do. FAA primary radar does not measure an object's size, and in that area it could not see anything below about 2,500 to 3,000 feet, so low-flying “chase jets” of the kind Allen described would not appear at all.

McGaha called the analysis “cherry picking.” In his account the authors had chosen 187 points “out of 2.5 million points of noise and scatter to make a [radar] track moving forty-nine mph for over one hour,” adding: “This analysis is absurd!” Schulze and Powell, for their part, held that the jets alone did not explain what they found. Neither side has moved since.

A radar return is data

The radar dispute turns on a distinction David Dell draws in The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory. Writing in its first chapter, “The Saucers We Thought We Knew,” about the radar targets over Washington in 1952, the book says: “An instrument can record something real without the observer's interpretation of that recording being correct. A radar return is data. Its identification as a solid object moving at extraordinary speed is an interpretation of that data.”

Stephenville has both kinds of evidence, and the same rule applies to each. The witnesses saw real lights. The FAA recorded real returns. Whether those lights were flares, afterburners and the human habit of joining dots, and whether a slow return without a transponder was a small aircraft, clutter or something else, are interpretations. Each has to stand on its own reasoning. An Air Force denial that turned out wrong does not prove a cover-up, and a radar track that points at the president's ranch does not prove a visitor.

What happened to Stephenville afterward

The town split, the Times found, into believers and skeptics. Allen did not accept the F-16 answer: “Our military wishes it had what we saw.” Gaitan reasoned that he had probably seen a military experiment the Air Force could not fully disclose, yet kept watching the sky, and in February filmed more lights with his police camera. Joiner, who had never seen the lights herself, left the paper, joined a radio show that covers unexplained phenomena as a special correspondent, and that April spoke at the National Press Club about covering the story. History's UFO Hunters made an episode of the case. Today the Stephenville lights sit on most lists of the major American mass sightings, with a footnote about ten fighter jets that nobody disputes and a radar track that everybody does.

A sign in the sky?

Stephenville is a deeply religious community, the Times noted, and some residents read the lights in those terms. A Bible study group at the Bread of Life Ministries discussed the sighting, the Times reported. One member wondered whether the lights were guardian angels. Her husband, the pastor, was less sure: “Could be the military. Could be the end of times.”

Scripture does speak of signs from heaven before the end:

“And great earthquakes shall be in divers places, and famines, and pestilences; and fearful sights and great signs shall there be from heaven.” Luke 21:11 (KJV)

It also tells believers not to take every sight at face value:

“Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.” 1 John 4:1 (KJV)

The Watchers Among Us asks readers to look past the machine for a different reason. It calls the lights we chase “glimpses of an interdimensional realm, home to the fallen angels of biblical lore,” and speaks of “a presence that's been alongside us all along—watching, waiting, deceiving.” Much of what flew over Erath County that night was what the FAA logged. For the lights that remain, the book's questions stand: “Are they testing us? Shaping us?” It dares readers “to rethink the lights—and the shadows they cast.”

Fourteen months before Stephenville, a dozen United Airlines employees at Chicago O’Hare watched a gray disc hover over a gate in daylight and leave through the overcast, and the FAA called it a weather phenomenon: the O’Hare UFO sighting of 2006. Fifty years earlier, out on the South Plains near Lubbock, drivers around Levelland reported a glowing object that stalled their cars; the Air Force file on that night was released in 2026: the Levelland UFO case of 1957. Other mass sightings argued over as aircraft and flares are the Phoenix Lights (1997) and the Hudson Valley UFO sightings of 1983 to at least 1987. F-16s also chased radar targets over Belgium: the Belgian UFO wave of 1989–90. Radar and visual reports first collided over an American city in the 1952 Washington, D.C. UFO flap. For the question of whether some of these lights are spiritual rather than extraterrestrial, see the interdimensional theory of UFOs and Are UFOs demons? A Christian view.

Common questions

When was the Stephenville UFO sighting?

The main sighting was on the evening of January 8, 2008, roughly between 6 and 8 p.m., around Stephenville, Selden and Dublin in Erath County, Texas. Some witnesses reported further lights in the following weeks.

What is the official explanation for the Stephenville lights?

On January 23, 2008, the Air Force Reserve said ten F-16s from the 457th Fighter Squadron were training in the nearby Brownwood airspace between 6 and 8 p.m. that night, correcting its earlier statement that no aircraft were in the area. Skeptics add that the jets were dropping flares.

Was the Stephenville UFO debunked?

Skeptics, led by James McGaha, consider it explained by F-16s, afterburners and flares, and point to FAA records that put eight F-16s beside Stephenville from 6:17 to 6:58 p.m. Many witnesses, and the MUFON radar study, do not accept that the jets account for everything that was seen.

What did the Stephenville radar data show?

MUFON's Glen Schulze and Robert Powell analyzed 2.8 million FAA radar returns and reported an unknown target without a transponder, tracked for over an hour and heading toward President Bush's Crawford ranch. McGaha called the analysis cherry-picking from radar noise.

How big was the Stephenville UFO?

Steve Allen estimated it at about a mile long and half a mile wide, “bigger than a Wal-Mart.” Size estimates of lights at night depend on knowing their distance, which no witness did, and FAA radar does not measure size.

Sources: Denise Gellene, How UFOs took over a town, Los Angeles Times (June 14, 2008) · Wade Goodwyn, Dozens Claim They Spotted UFO in Texas, NPR (Jan. 16, 2008) · Mike Mount, UFOs? Nope. They were fighter jets, Air Force says, CNN (Jan. 23, 2008) · FAA FOIA release 2009-003019 (Jan. 17–18, 2008 ZFW ARTCC emails), The Black Vault · Glen Schulze and Robert Powell, Stephenville Lights: A Comprehensive Radar and Witness Report Study, MUFON (via NICAP) · James McGaha and Joe Nickell, Alien Lights? At Phoenix, Stephenville, and Elsewhere: A Postmortem, Skeptical Inquirer 39:2 (2015) · UFO Case: Stephenville, Texas (January 08, 2008), The Black Vault · Luke 21:11; 1 John 4:1 (KJV)

Cover of The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell

Get the book

The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell. Its first chapter, “The Saucers We Thought We Knew,” keeps apart what an instrument records and what an observer decides it means: “A radar return is data.” Whether such lights are glimpses of an interdimensional realm is the question of David Dell's shorter book, The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon.

More questions

Home · The Great Deception · Reading guide: Watchers in Scripture