Are fairies fallen angels? Demons, the Good People, and the UFO connection
Irish islanders called them fallen angels. A Scottish minister called them the Good People. The ballads sent them to the gates of hell. And the stories they told look a great deal like modern alien abduction.
In the 1880s, Lady Wilde wrote down what Irish islanders believed about the fairies. Her answer was blunt: “The islanders, like all the Irish, believe that the fairies are the fallen angels who were cast down by the Lord God out of heaven for their sinful pride.” Some fell into the sea, some onto dry land, and some deep into hell. The ones that fell into hell were given “knowledge and power” by the devil and sent “on earth where they work much evil.”
That is not a modern UFO writer's theory. It is old Christian folk belief, recorded long before anyone had seen a flying saucer. The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell gives the fairy tradition a full chapter, “Taken by the Good People,” because the old stories of people carried off by beautiful, untrustworthy beings have the same shape as the abduction reports of the last seventy years. Dell's point is about the shape. In his words: “Now remove the words fairy and elf from the story.”
Are fairies in the Bible?
No. The words “fairy” and “fairies” do not appear anywhere in the King James Bible, and neither do “elf” or “elves.” What Scripture does describe is an unseen order of created beings alongside the visible one:
“For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:” Colossians 1:16 (KJV)
It also says that some of those beings rebelled and fell:
“And the angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgment of the great day.” Jude 1:6 (KJV)
The Bible names men, angels, and fallen angels. It does not name a third race living in the hills. So when Christian communities met the older belief in an invisible people who could help or harm, the question was where those beings fit. The Irish islanders gave one answer. A Scottish minister gave another, and it sounds almost the same.
The Good People: Robert Kirk's Secret Commonwealth
Robert Kirk was born in 1644 and served as the minister of Aberfoyle, in the wooded hills of the southern Scottish Highlands. He also helped bring religious texts into Gaelic. Around 1691 he finished The Secret Commonwealth of Elves, Fauns, and Fairies, a careful description of what his parishioners believed about the hidden population around them. His first chapter begins with the name they used:
“These Siths, or Fairies, they call Sleagh Maith, or the Good People”
The flattering name was not praise. Kirk says the people called them that to turn aside their “ill attempts,” and he describes them as “of a middle nature betwixt man and angel, as were daemons thought to be of old.” They were normally invisible, could appear and disappear at will, and lived in the hills. As Dell puts it in The Great Deception, “The title was not necessarily a compliment. Sometimes, it was a precaution.”
Taken: the women who nursed fairy children
Kirk's fourth chapter contains the part of his book that reads most like a modern case file:
“Women are yet alive who tell they were taken away when in child-bed to nurse fairy children”
A likeness of the woman was left in her place. It seemed to eat, then seemed to die a natural death. When the fairy child was weaned, the woman either died, was brought back, or chose to stay. Kirk adds that people in the Highlands would “put bread, the Bible, or a piece of iron, in women's beds” to keep them from being stolen this way.
Dell opens his chapter with the most elaborate of these stories: a woman mourned and buried, who later came back and said the woman in the grave was a substitute, and that she had been held to care for one of the beings' children. Now read it as a modern report. A woman is taken without consent by unfamiliar beings. She is involved with their offspring. A false copy stands in for her. When she comes back, no one quite believes her. Abduction researchers would recognize every element, and in the seventeenth century, Dell notes, the story “required no spaceships.”
Changelings
The same fear turned toward the cradle. In changeling folklore, the fairies stole a baby and left one of their own, or an old fairy disguised as an infant, in its place. Lady Wilde recorded these stories in Ireland, including “The Fairy Changeling,” in which a man on his way home overhears two women at a window arranging to leave “the dead child in the cradle” and carry the living one to “the fairy queen.”
Dell does not romanticize this material. Families sometimes treated sick or disabled children as intruders because of it, and real children suffered. But he draws one plain lesson from the tradition: the stories show that “the fear of deceptive appearances is much older than the modern UFO phenomenon.” Modern abduction literature has its own version, with claims of beings who interfere with human reproduction and create hybrid offspring.
Thomas the Rhymer and the Queen of Elfland
The Scottish ballad of Thomas the Rhymer is the clearest example of a being who presents itself as holy and is not. Thomas, a real thirteenth-century figure from the Scottish Borders, is lying on a grassy bank when a lady rides up in grass-green silk. He greets her as heaven's queen:
“All hail, thou mighty Queen of Heaven! For your peer on earth I never did see.”
“O no, O no, True Thomas,” she says, “That name does not belong to me; I am but the queen of fair Elfland”
She takes him away to serve her seven years. On the way she shows him three roads: the narrow path of righteousness, the broad road, and a third, “the road to fair Elfland.” Of the broad road the ballad says: “That is the path of wickedness, Tho some call it the road to heaven.” He is told to keep silent in her country or never come home, and “till seven years were past and gone True Thomas on earth was never seen.” He came back with a reputation as a prophet.
A being mistaken for a heavenly figure, a captive taken to another realm, years that vanish, and a return with special knowledge. Dell sets it beside Betty and Barney Hill, who said the beings had knowledge of distant stars, and Travis Walton, who came back with five days missing. The ballad also echoes a warning Paul gave:
“And no marvel; for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light.” 2 Corinthians 11:14 (KJV)
Tam Lin and the teind to hell
In the ballad of Tam Lin, collected by Francis James Child, a young man fell from his horse while hunting and was caught by the Queen of Fairies. Fairyland is pleasant, he tells Janet, the woman who finds him at Carterhaugh, but there is a price:
“Ay at the end of seven years We pay a tiend to hell”
A teind is a tithe, and Tam Lin is afraid he will be the payment. On Halloween night Janet pulls him from his horse as the fairy procession rides past and holds on while the queen changes him into one terrifying shape after another. She doesn't let go, and he becomes a man again. In this ballad the fairies are tied to hell itself. Dell points out that captive humans, a ruler who controls the captives, and appearances that keep changing are also staples of modern encounter reports, where witnesses describe beings who seem to alter what they see.
Missing time, centuries before UFOs
Abductees often report missing time. Irish literature has a much older version. In The Voyage of Bran, Bran sails to a land beyond the sea where no one ages. When he and his men come home, Ireland remembers his voyage only as an ancient story, and when Nechtan steps ashore he turns to ashes, as though the centuries caught up with him at once. Oisín and the Land of Youth carries the same theme. Dell sums it up simply: time in the otherworld “is not necessarily time as humans understand it.” Missing hours are covered case by case on Betty and Barney Hill's 1961 abduction and Travis Walton and the 1975 Fire in the Sky abduction.
What Augustine said about incubi
Christians were asking about spirits and human contact long before Kirk. In The City of God, Book XV, chapter 23, Augustine discusses reports of “sylvans and fauns, who are commonly called incubi” and their assaults on women. He says the reports are so widely affirmed “that it were impudent to deny it,” but he does not decide what such spirits are. On Genesis 6 he is firm: “certainly I could by no means believe that God's holy angels could at that time have so fallen.” Dell's chapter uses Augustine to show how old the question is and how carefully the great teachers handled it. The Genesis 6 debate itself is on Who were the sons of God in Genesis 6?
From the fairy-faith to the flying saucer
Belief in fairies did not end with the Middle Ages. Between 1908 and 1910 Walter Evans-Wentz traveled through Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Cornwall, Brittany, and the Isle of Man, collecting the testimony of people who still believed, and some who said they had seen the beings: strange lights, unusual figures, music from nowhere. He published it in 1911 as The Fairy-Faith in Celtic Countries. Thirty-six years later, American newspapers were full of flying saucers. As Dell notes, “The historical distance between the two traditions was therefore smaller than many readers might imagine.”
In 1969 Jacques Vallée made the comparison famous in Passport to Magonia, setting UFO occupant reports beside fairy lore. His work, and John Keel's, is on Jacques Vallée, John Keel, and J. Allen Hynek, and the idea that the beings come from a realm alongside ours rather than another planet is on the interdimensional theory of UFOs.
So, are fairies demons?
The tradition answered for itself. Irish islanders said fallen angels. Kirk's neighbors put a Bible in the bed to keep them away. Tam Lin's fairies paid tribute to hell. Thomas's queen was mistaken for the Queen of Heaven and showed him a broad road that some call the road to heaven. A being that hides behind a flattering name, takes people against their will, and passes itself off as heavenly is not hard to place in a Christian frame. The Bible gives the test:
“Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.” 1 John 4:1 (KJV)
That is the thread The Great Deception follows from the fairy hills to the flying saucer. A new name does not change what the visitor is. Near the end of the chapter he puts the old warning in new words: “Something that appears extraordinary is not necessarily what it claims to be.” And the question that matters most is the one the ballads kept asking: “Can the visitor be trusted?” How Scripture describes the fallen angels and demons is on Are demons fallen angels? and What happened to the fallen angels?, and the modern form of the question is on Are UFOs demons?
Are fairies fallen angels in the Bible?
The Bible does not mention fairies. The belief that fairies are fallen angels comes from Christian folklore, recorded in Ireland by Lady Wilde, who wrote that the islanders believed the fairies were angels cast out of heaven for their pride.
Are fairies demonic in Christianity?
Many Christians have thought so. Scripture names only men, angels, and fallen angels, and the old stories describe beings that deceive, steal people away, and, in the ballad of Tam Lin, pay a tribute to hell.
What is a changeling?
In European folklore, a changeling is a fairy left in place of a stolen human baby. Robert Kirk also recorded adult versions: women taken to nurse fairy children, with a likeness of them left behind.
Why are fairies called the Good People?
Out of caution. Robert Kirk recorded the Gaelic name Sleagh Maith, “the Good People,” and explained it as a way to ward off their “ill attempts.”
Sources: Lady Wilde, Ancient Legends, Mystic Charms & Superstitions of Ireland (“The Fairies as Fallen Angels”; “The Fairy Changeling”), Project Gutenberg · Robert Kirk, The Secret Commonwealth of Elves, Fauns, and Fairies, chapters I and IV (University of Oregon, Enchanted) · Thomas Rymer, Child Ballad 37A · Tam Lin, Child Ballad 39A · Augustine, The City of God, Book XV, chapter 23 (New Advent) · Walter Evans-Wentz, The Fairy-Faith in Celtic Countries (1911) · Colossians 1:16; Jude 1:6; 2 Corinthians 11:14; 1 John 4:1 (KJV)
