Is sleep paralysis demonic? The Old Hag, the night demon, and the alien at the bedside
You wake and cannot move. Something is in the room, and it is coming closer. Christians have called it a demon, Newfoundlanders called it the Old Hag, and modern witnesses call it an alien. Here is what the experience is, what Scripture says about terror by night, and how one Christian investigation answers the question.
The pattern is old and remarkably consistent. A person surfaces from sleep into a familiar, quiet bedroom. The arms will not move. A shout comes out as nothing. Then comes the presence: a dark figure by the wall, a weight on the chest, sometimes a voice, sometimes a feeling of being lifted off the mattress. Then movement returns, the figure is gone, and the door is still closed.
The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell gives this experience its own chapter, “The Bedroom, the Brain, and the Threshold,” because it sits under so many modern abduction reports. Dell opens with the questions a frightened sleeper actually asks: “Was it an attempted alien abduction? A demonic attack? An encounter with an invisible intelligence? Or did the brain produce the entire event?” His answer is direct: “The human brain is capable of producing this experience without any external visitor at all.” And his Christian conclusion is just as direct: “Christian theology does not require every frightening dream to be a demonic encounter.”
What happens in sleep paralysis
During REM sleep, the dreaming stage, the brain switches off most voluntary muscles so the body does not act out its dreams. Sleep researchers call this REM atonia. Sleep paralysis happens when awareness of the real room comes back before the atonia lets go. The sleeper sees the ceiling and hears the house, but the body is still in dream mode, and dream imagery can keep running on top of the real room. An episode can last seconds or a few minutes.
It is common. A 2011 review of 35 studies and 36,533 people put lifetime prevalence at 7.6 percent of the general population, higher among students and psychiatric patients. It does not need mental illness behind it. Short sleep, broken schedules, and stress make it more likely. As Dell puts it, “A person can be entirely sane, genuinely frightened, and completely mistaken about the cause of an experience.”
A 2021 study in the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine caught episodes on laboratory recordings. One participant, a 27-year-old woman with years of episodes, described seeing “a black demon moving and speaking with an incomprehensible language” and feeling pressure on her chest. In the lab, one of her episodes began, by her own report, at the first boom of the National Day fireworks over the Eiffel Tower in Paris, which the recording also picked up, and lasted five minutes. She ended it in a false awakening, dreaming that she had pressed the button to call the nurse. Across the participants, the brain rhythms during sleep paralysis sat much closer to REM sleep than to waking. The authors concluded that the brain during sleep paralysis “is not in an awake but in a dreaming state.”
Why it feels like someone is in the room
In 1999, the psychologists James Allan Cheyne, Steve Rueffer, and Ian Newby-Clark sorted sleep-paralysis hallucinations into three groups: the intruder (fear, a sensed presence, sights and sounds), the incubus (chest pressure, trouble breathing, a sense of assault), and unusual body experiences (floating, flying, leaving the body). Put those three together and the result reads like an abduction: a figure by the bed, a body held down, a rise toward the ceiling.
The sense of presence, the part witnesses find most convincing, has been produced in a laboratory. In 2014, Olaf Blanke's team in Lausanne and Geneva published a study in Current Biology in which healthy volunteers worked a robot in front of them while a second robot touched their backs. When the touch was delayed, some volunteers felt that another person was standing behind them and touching them. The researchers concluded that the illusion of another person nearby comes from misreading the source of the body's own signals. Dell draws the lesson in one line: “An invisible visitor can feel real even when nobody is there.”
The sleep paralysis demon has many names
The figure on the chest has been named in nearly every culture that has slept alone in the dark:
- The Old Hag. In Newfoundland, a person attacked in the night by the Old Hag is said to have been “hag-ridden.”
- The mare. The English word “nightmare” comes from the mare or mara, a spirit said to sit on and suffocate sleepers. Samuel Johnson's 1755 Dictionary still defined the nightmare as an oppression in the night like a weight on the breast. Henry Fuseli's 1781 painting The Nightmare, now in the Detroit Institute of Arts, puts a crouching demon on a sleeping woman's chest. In 1969 the physician Jerome Schneck pointed out in JAMA that the scene has the features of sleep paralysis.
- The incubus and succubus. In European tradition, male and female night spirits blamed for paralysis, pressure, and unwanted contact.
- Kanashibari. In Japan, “metal binding.”
- Ghost oppression in parts of China, the Karabasan in Turkey, and the pisadeira in Brazil, a figure said to press on sleepers' chests.
- Jinn. In parts of the Arab world the chest-sitter is called Al-Jathoom and is believed to be a jinn.
The folklorist David J. Hufford studied the Old Hag in Newfoundland for his 1982 book The Terror That Comes in the Night. The easy explanation was that people who believe in a night hag will dream of one. Hufford found it worked the other way round often enough to matter. Some people had the experience first and only later learned their community had a name for it. Dell takes the point seriously: “It would be too simplistic to suggest that people see demons merely because they believe in demons, or that people see aliens merely because they have watched science-fiction movies.” The core experience comes first. Culture supplies the costume. In his summary, “The names differ. The surrounding beliefs differ. But the reported sensations often overlap.”
From the incubus to the Grey
The newest name on that list is the alien. A modern witness wakes to small figures beside the bed, cannot move, hears without words, and feels carried upward. Dell's reading is that the old night visitor and the modern one are often the same human experience under a new label: “a frightening nocturnal episode once attributed to an incubus may be understood today as an encounter with a Grey alien.” The false awakening makes the case harder to judge. A person can dream that they have woken up in an accurate copy of their own bedroom, meet a figure there, and remember the whole sequence as a waking event. The bedroom looking right does not show that the person was awake.
Memory can then grow the story. In a 2002 study, Susan Clancy, Richard McNally, Daniel Schacter, and colleagues found that people who reported recovered memories of alien abduction were more prone to a laboratory false-memory error than controls. A figure by the bed can become, after reading and hypnosis, an examination table and a message. The earliest famous case of that kind is Betty and Barney Hill's 1961 abduction.
Dell draws a sharper point from this than the skeptics do. If people have always met the same night presence and named it after whatever their age believed in, then the experience is a door that anything wanting to deceive could walk through. In his words: “A deceptive being might not need to introduce an entirely new concept. It might only need to assume a form humanity was already prepared to believe.”
What does the Bible say about sleep paralysis?
Scripture never names sleep paralysis, but it does describe a terror that comes at night. The most vivid account belongs to Eliphaz, one of Job's friends:
“In thoughts from the visions of the night, when deep sleep falleth on men, Fear came upon me, and trembling, which made all my bones to shake. Then a spirit passed before my face; the hair of my flesh stood up: It stood still, but I could not discern the form thereof: an image was before mine eyes, there was silence, and I heard a voice, saying,” Job 4:13–16 (KJV)
Deep sleep, overwhelming fear, a presence whose shape cannot be made out, silence, and a voice: Eliphaz's night visitor has every mark of the experience on this page. What the spirit told him matters too. Eliphaz built his case against Job on it, and at the end of the book God rejects that case:
“And it was so, that after the LORD had spoken these words unto Job, the LORD said to Eliphaz the Temanite, My wrath is kindled against thee, and against thy two friends: for ye have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant Job hath.” Job 42:7 (KJV)
A fearful presence in the night spoke, and its message was not the last word. That is the question The Great Deception keeps asking of modern visitors. As Dell puts it, “If an unfamiliar intelligence genuinely exists, its extraordinary appearance would not by itself establish that it is truthful.” The other night verses in Scripture point the sleeper away from fear, not toward a diagnosis:
“Thou shalt not be afraid for the terror by night; nor for the arrow that flieth by day;” Psalm 91:5 (KJV)
“When thou liest down, thou shalt not be afraid: yea, thou shalt lie down, and thy sleep shall be sweet.” Proverbs 3:24 (KJV)
“I will both lay me down in peace, and sleep: for thou, LORD, only makest me dwell in safety.” Psalm 4:8 (KJV)
So is sleep paralysis demonic?
The answer in The Great Deception has two halves, and Dell holds both. The paralysis, the presence, the pressure, and the floating have a known mechanism, and an episode does not by itself show that a spirit entered the room. And that mechanism does not disprove the spiritual world: “A person may believe in God, angels, demons, and the spiritual dimension of existence while also recognizing that the nervous system can produce unusual experiences. The two propositions are not logically incompatible.” Neurology explains how the experience is produced. Theology speaks about angels, demons, and God. “Sometimes those questions overlap. But they should not be confused.”
He gives a pastoral reason for getting this right. A person who decides that every episode is an attack can end up more afraid, sleeping worse, and having more episodes: “A frightening experience could therefore reinforce the interpretation that makes it more frightening.” His counsel is to take the sufferer seriously without feeding the fear, and that recurring episodes, especially with heavy daytime sleepiness, are worth a doctor's evaluation. For a Christian, the verse for that night is plain:
“For God hath not given us the spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind.” 2 Timothy 1:7 (KJV)
And for the Great Deception hypothesis itself, Dell argues that the bedroom cases have to be set aside before the hard cases are weighed. Counting a known sleep state as evidence of fallen angels “would not strengthen the argument. It would weaken it.” The cases that test a spiritual reading are the ones sleep cannot reach: many witnesses, awake, outdoors, at the same time, such as the 1955 Kelly-Hopkinsville encounter and the 1994 Ariel School UFO encounter.
What about saying the name of Jesus?
Some Christians say an episode ended the moment they called on Jesus, and some UFO researchers collected abduction reports that broke off the same way. Dell treats those reports in the chapter just before his sleep chapter, together with the sleep-paralysis reading of them, and that discussion is on alien abductions stopped by the name of Jesus. Whether demons are fallen angels in the first place is on Are demons fallen angels?, and the older night visitors of folklore are on Are fairies fallen angels?
Sources: Brian A. Sharpless and Jacques P. Barber, Lifetime prevalence rates of sleep paralysis: a systematic review, Sleep Medicine Reviews (2011), PubMed · Greta Mainieri et al., Are sleep paralysis and false awakenings different from REM sleep and from lucid REM sleep? A spectral EEG analysis, Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine 17(4) (2021) · J. A. Cheyne, S. D. Rueffer, and I. R. Newby-Clark, Hypnagogic and hypnopompic hallucinations during sleep paralysis, Consciousness and Cognition (1999), PubMed · Olaf Blanke et al., Neurological and robot-controlled induction of an apparition, Current Biology 24(22) (2014) · This robot makes you feel like a ‘ghost’ is in the room, EurekAlert! (2014) · David J. Hufford, The Terror That Comes in the Night (University of Pennsylvania Press, 1982) · Sleep paralysis (Old Hag, kanashibari, Al-Jathoom), Wikipedia · Henry Fuseli, The Nightmare (1781), Smarthistory · Painting a nightmare, Sleep Health (Schneck 1969 and sleep paralysis) · Susan A. Clancy et al., Memory distortion in people reporting abduction by aliens, Journal of Abnormal Psychology (2002), PubMed · Job 4:13–16; Job 42:7; Psalm 91:5; Proverbs 3:24; Psalm 4:8; 2 Timothy 1:7 (KJV)
