The Nimitz “Tic Tac” UFO: what happened in 2004?

On 14 November 2004, off the coast of southern California, Navy fighter crews from the USS Nimitz carrier strike group were sent to check radar returns that didn't match any known aircraft. What they reported became the best-known military UFO case of the century so far, usually called the “Tic Tac” after the shape of the object. Here is what was said on the record, how the video reached the public, and how skeptics explain it.

What the lead pilot said under oath

Commander David Fravor, then commanding officer of Strike Fighter Squadron 41 (VFA-41), testified to a House Oversight subcommittee on July 26, 2023. The quotes below are from the official transcript. He said the ship's radar had been watching objects for days:

“these objects had been observed for over 2 weeks coming down from over 80,000 feet, rapidly descending to 20,000 feet, hanging out for hours and then going straight back up.”

Sent to investigate during a training exercise, his crew and a second jet “looked down and saw a white Tic Tac object with a longitudinal axis pointing north south and moving very abruptly over the water like a ping pong ball.” He said: “There were no rotors, no rotor wash, or any sign of visible control surfaces like wings.” When a member of Congress asked whether it was a “40-foot flying Tic Tac shaped object,” Fravor answered: “That is correct.”

As he turned toward it, he said, “within about a half mile of it, it rapidly accelerated in front of us and disappeared.” Moments later a controller told them: “sir, you are not going to believe this, but that thing is at your CAP point roughly 60 miles away in less than a minute.” Fravor added that the cruiser USS Princeton, the Nimitz and an E-2 radar plane tracked it, but “We never saw it on our radars.” His conclusion: the object “was far superior to anything that we had on time, have today, or looking to develop in the next 10 years.”

The other pilot in the encounter, Alex Dietrich, has also spoken publicly; she and Fravor said four aircrew in total watched the object for about five minutes.

Where the “Tic Tac” name and the video came from

A second flight later that day included Lieutenant Commander Chad Underwood, whose jet carried an infrared targeting camera (FLIR). Underwood recorded the video now known as “FLIR” and coined the “Tic Tac” description, partly, he later said, from a joke in the 1980 comedy Airplane!. He didn't see the object with his own eyes; he was watching his screen.

The video's road to the public was slow:

Later official releases are dated and summarized on the UAP files release timeline, and the full 2023 hearing is in The UAP hearings explained.

How skeptics explain it

Skeptics usually grant that the aircrew were sincere and argue the case is weaker than it sounds:

Those who take the case seriously answer that the witness accounts, and the radar tracking Fravor described, go well beyond one fuzzy clip. The 2020 release, though, covered the videos only. With so little else public, the case is still argued both ways.

A Christian view

Two things can be true at once: experienced aviators saw something they couldn't identify, and a sighting isn't the same as an explanation. Scripture asks for that kind of patience:

“Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” 1 Thessalonians 5:21 (KJV)

What the Bible adds is a reminder that “unidentified” doesn't have to mean “from another planet.” It describes an unseen realm that is normally hidden and occasionally becomes visible, as when Elisha's servant saw what was already around him:

“And Elisha prayed, and said, LORD, I pray thee, open his eyes, that he may see. And the LORD opened the eyes of the young man; and he saw: and, behold, the mountain was full of horses and chariots of fire round about Elisha.” 2 Kings 6:17 (KJV)

That doesn't tell us what the Tic Tac was. It does widen the list of possibilities beyond hardware, which is the idea behind the interdimensional theory of UFOs, and it raises the question taken up in Are UFOs demons? and Is UFO disclosure a deception?

The longer investigation is The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell. Places a well-known modern case in a longer investigation of how UFO stories are told, and of the explanations that still have to be tested. The short book is The Watchers Among Us: Unveiling the Spiritual Truth of the UFO Phenomenon. A short introduction that opens, “What if everything you thought you knew about UFOs was wrong?” It does not discuss the Nimitz case.

Sources: Hearing transcript, July 26, 2023 (PDF) · DoD statement, April 27, 2020 · Pentagon UFO videos · 1 Thessalonians 5:21; 2 Kings 6:17 (KJV)

Cover of The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell

Get the book

The Great Deception: UFOs, Fallen Angels, and the Alien False-Flag Theory by David Dell. Places a well-known modern case in a longer investigation of how UFO stories are told, and of the explanations that still have to be tested.

More questions

Home · Free reading guide: Watchers in Scripture